The headline One idea, three platforms, beside a card listing Facebook, Instagram and LinkedIn versions checked by a person.

One Idea, Three Platforms: Writing Social Posts With AI

AI can turn one idea into a LinkedIn post, an Instagram caption and a Facebook post in one go, but only if you give it the facts and a different job for each platform. Ask it to “write posts for LinkedIn, Instagram and Facebook” and you get the same paragraph at three lengths, with a few claims you never made. Below is the prompt we use, what happened when we tested it on one of our own stories, and what a person still has to check.

Why Not Post the Same Thing Everywhere?

Because people scroll each platform for different reasons. On LinkedIn, people read for a lesson from someone’s work. On Instagram, the picture does most of the talking and the caption backs it up. On Facebook, local customers want something short and useful from a business they know. We cover the formats themselves in Instagram vs Facebook post types.

The platforms also set hard limits:

Platform Official limit What we aim for
LinkedIn Up to 3,000 characters per post 100 to 300 words, 3 to 5 hashtags
Instagram Captions up to 2,200 characters and 30 hashtags (from Meta’s developer documentation) 1 to 3 short sentences, 3 to 5 hashtags, an image that works on its own
Facebook We didn’t need one: our posts are short 1 to 3 sentences, no more than 2 hashtags

The right-hand column is our own house style, not a platform rule. Nobody needs a 3,000-character post. The point is that the same words don’t fit all three, so you need three versions of the idea, not three copies of the text.

What Happened When We Tested It?

A basic prompt wrote three versions that said the same thing, and every one claimed something that wasn’t true. For the test, we used a real story of our own: we’d tested AI on our Google review replies and found that all eight of our posted replies opened with “Thank you”. (That test is its own post: how to reply to Google reviews with AI.)

First we asked for posts the way most people do: “Write a LinkedIn post, an Instagram caption and a Facebook post about how we tested AI on our Google review replies.” Then we used the prompt below, with a short list of facts.

Basic prompt The prompt below
Different opening on each platform No, all three start “We tested…” Yes
Claims the facts don’t support 4 across the three posts 0
Hashtags (LinkedIn, Instagram, Facebook) 6, 10, 3 3, 3, 0
Uses the most interesting fact No Yes, on all three

The invented claims were the worrying part. The Instagram caption said “AI wrote our review replies”, which it didn’t: the test drafts were never posted. The Facebook post promised AI “can save small businesses hours every week”, a number nobody gave it. The LinkedIn post said AI “can help you sound more personal”, the opposite of what the basic prompt did in our test. Each sounds harmless until a customer quotes it back to you.

The Prompt We Use

Copy this, fill in the brackets, and keep the facts list honest. We tested it in Claude. It’s plain text, so it works in whichever AI assistant you already use.

I run [BUSINESS NAME], a [TYPE OF BUSINESS] in [TOWN].
We sound [HOW YOU TALK, e.g. "plain-spoken and friendly"].
The idea for this week: [ONE SENTENCE]
Facts you can use (use nothing else):
- [FACT]
- [FACT]
- [FACT]
What I want people to do: [e.g. "read the blog post",
"call for a quote", "come to the open day on Saturday"]
Write three posts about this one idea:
1. LinkedIn: 100 to 300 words. Open with a sentence that makes
   someone stop scrolling. Short paragraphs. Tell it as a lesson
   we learned. 3 hashtags at the end.
2. Instagram: 1 to 3 short sentences that work under a photo.
   Suggest the photo. 3 hashtags.
3. Facebook: 1 to 3 sentences for local customers. Give them one
   useful thing. No hashtags.
Rules for all three:
- Give each post a different opening and a different angle.
  Don't write one post and shorten it.
- Use only the facts above. No numbers, results or promises
  that aren't in the list.
- No emojis unless I ask. No hype words or stock phrases.
- If a post needs something I haven't given you, such as a link
  or a date, write [CHECK: what's missing] instead of guessing.

The facts list does most of the work. If a fact isn’t on the list, the prompt tells the AI it can’t use it, and that rule is what stopped the “hours every week” kind of claim.

What Did the Three Posts Look Like?

Three different ways into the same story. These are the drafts from our test, after a person’s edits.

LinkedIn (shortened here):

We read our own Google review replies the way a stranger would, and didn’t love what we found.

All eight started with “Thank you”. Two slipped in a pitch for our services.

So we tested AI on the same eight reviews. A basic prompt made it worse: every draft opened “Thank you so much”, and one thanked a client for a search ranking they never mentioned.

In our test, AI copied whatever habits we gave it, including the ones we hadn’t noticed.

Instagram, under an image card that reads “8 of 8 opened with ‘Thank you'”:

Eight Google review replies. Eight that opened with “Thank you”. We only noticed when we read them side by side. The fix, and the prompt, is on our blog. Link in bio.

Facebook:

If you reply to Google reviews, try this: read your last eight replies in a row. Ours all opened with “Thank you”, so we wrote an AI prompt to break the habit. Here it is: [link]

LinkedIn gets the lesson, Instagram gets the surprising number, and Facebook gets something the reader can try today.

What Should a Person Check Before Posting?

Four things, and the first one matters most.

  1. Is every claim on your facts list? The AI drafted the LinkedIn post’s last line as “AI copies whatever habits you give it”, which is a big claim from one test. We changed it to “in our test”, because that’s what we actually know.
  2. Is anything missing? Every [CHECK] marker needs a real answer. On ours, the Facebook post needed the actual link, and “link in bio” only works if someone updates the bio.
  3. Does it need a picture you don’t have yet? The Instagram caption only works with the image card. Someone has to make it.
  4. Does it show or name a customer? If a post names a client, shows their team or shows their premises, get their written permission first. An AI draft won’t know to ask.

Where Do the Ideas Come From?

From your week, not from the AI. The best social posts start with something real: a job you finished, a question a customer asked, a mistake you fixed. AI is good at turning that into three posts. It’s poor at making up the idea in the first place, because it doesn’t know what happened in your business this week.

A simple habit works: once a week, write down one thing that happened, three facts about it, and what you’d like people to do next. That’s the whole input. If you also post on your Google Business Profile, the same idea can become a fourth post using our Google Business Profile prompt.

The Part Worth Remembering

AI saves you the rewriting, not the thinking. Our basic prompt wrote three confident posts in seconds, and every one needed fixing. The prompt with a facts list wrote three posts we could actually use, after a person changed one sentence.

If you’d like help planning and scheduling social posts so they go out every week without you remembering, book a demo and we’ll show you how it works for a business like yours.

Social Share:

Related Post